This post is in response to Seven Reasons Why the New iPhone Sucks from DivineCaroline.com. Please refer to this if you need to know what I am talking about.
1.Too expensive to own.
Really? How much does a standard cell phone on AT&T cost with unlimited internet, text messaging, and voice run? AT&T charges $39.99 for the standard voice plan, plus $30.00 for unlimited internet on any 3G enabled smartphone, and between $5 and $20 for text messaging, for a grand total of $74.99-$89.99 per month. No, it is not a cheap plan, but it is exactly the same as every other 3G phone availible through AT&T.
2. Can’t use the GPS like a GPS.
GOOD! I don’t want you driving around with an iPhone in one hand, and a double mocha latte in the other trying to find which exit to get off of on I95 anyway. Turn by turn on such a small device is not my idea of a good time.
3. Can’t tether the iPhone to your laptop.
Yes, there are plenty of phone that can be used to tether, and the iPhone is not “currently” one of them. I say currently because what AT&T doesn’t know won’t hurt them and my 1st Gen iPhone had bean tethered (over EDGE, yuk) to my MacBook using Jailbreak and an SSH connection. Once the 3G iPhone is Jailbroken, there will be ways of tethering and AT&T will not notice or care. This is not a great solution for everybody, but if you really care about tethering that bad, this will be the only way to go.
4. Still no cut and paste.
Get over it. Apple is working on it, and it is not as easy as everyone thinks. Sure the programing for it is a few simple lines of code, but getting it to incorperate with the UI is a whole other story. So in other words, calm down and wait.
5. Wimpy 2 MP camera.
I would cover the whole megapixel myth here, but I don’t have the patience or time. 2 megapixels is just fine for a phone. 3-5 megapixels is perfect for most point and shoots. In order to get better quality images, you don’t need megapixels, you need a better lense. Better lenses are significatly larger than what is currently in the iPhone. Look at some of the Carl Zeiss lenses in Nokia N-series phones. They are huge, and would take away from the iPhones petite form factor.
6. No stereo Bluetooth.
A2DP Stereo bluetooth is crap and it will suck the life out of the battery twice as fast as the 3G wireless chip in the iPhone. Steve Jobs is not an idiot, the 3G iPhone has some of the best battery life out of any 3G phone on the market and is not going to ruin that over a gimmick like wireless headphones.
7. The list goes on.
Still no Flash player for rich media content (what grudge does Steve Jobs hold against Adobe). Still can’t send pictures in MMS messages, still no native voice dialing, no mobile TV, no replaceable battery, no flash memory card, and on and on.
You can live without flash. I for one am greatful that as I browse the web on Mobile Safari, I am not bombarded by Flash based ads everywhere I go.
I feel text messaging itself is depreciated being that most phones have instant messagers and email, let alone sending anoying MMS messages. If you want to send me a picture, send it to my email. SMS and MMS are just another way for phone companies to charge you extra for bandwith you allready paid for.
Voice dialing might be nice, but I think most people have no problem going without it.
Mobile TV? iPhones have iTunes and a huge selection of TV and Movies so whats the point?
You know the pretty little form factor Apple came up with for the iPhone? Consider that ruined the minute you put an easy access battery cover on the back. Also, have you ever droped an iPhone? I have, and you know what doesn’t happen? The battery, battery cover, and phone do not go flying of in 3 seperate directions. I call that a feature.
Last but not least, memory cards. Why, you have at least 8gigabytes of storage? Is that not enough for you?
I will probably update this a bit more later, but my head hurts now, and I am going to have a beer.
[authors note] I do not have a 3G iPhone only because I am quite happy with my 8Gb first generation model.